Potbelly Restaurant New York 2024 ( Prices + menu + location )

Potbelly Restaurant New York Retro-style counter-serve chain known for made-to-order toasted sandwiches, salads & baked goods.

Potbelly Restaurant New York

• Type: Sandwich shop
• Rating of 5 stars: 4.2
• Audience:Family friendly Groups Tourists University students
• Seating places:No-contact delivery Delivery Takeaway Dine-in
• Dining options:Breakfast Lunch Dinner Catering Dessert Seating
• Worktime:, 9 AM–11 PM
  
• pricing: $
• Payments:Credit cards Debit cards NFC mobile payments
• Potbelly Restaurant New York phone number:+16462894205
• Potbelly Restaurant New York address:501 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States
• Get Location

Real experience

Amazing subs! Get the wreak, it’s their signature sub with different meats. The place is an old fashion
Sandwich shop and have a fast an efficient process to get customers in and out. Right when you walk in through the revolving door you know this is gonna be good and it is. I got the wreak with pickles mayo mustard oil lettuce tomato and it was perfect!! If you want a good New York City sub go to potbelly.

Potbelly Restaurant New York Menu

Reviews

comments 1

Just like Subway! I was sort of expecting that. Which is fine. I ordered the Italian on multi grain with hot peppers. The peppers had a little kick to it. The place is huge with practically no customers. Come eat while the place is still open for business. I am sure whoever owns this place is losing their shirt. The interior is huge and antique looking. Real cool atmosphere.

All the employees were absolutely wonderful. I walked to several places looking just for a slice of bread to give my daughter for an unsettled stomach. They allowed me to purchase some bread. Amazing job and helping a momma out. I returned to order the sandwich “A Wreck”. Very good fresh bread and plenty of meat and toppings. I would eat here again. Sometimes having friendly employees pays off.

comments 2

I love Potbelly’s. Been a fan for years. I’ve tried all the sandwiches and soups but I tend to stick to the mushroom melt. For some reason, I like the taste and texture of sauteed mushrooms with cheese.

I don’t go as often because it’s gotten pretty expensive these days, but if I get something in my rewards like a free cookie, I take advantage of it.

I don’t typically get meals. Just the sandwich. I go to this location often because it’s near the train that I take. There are other locations, but I can only review this one because it’s the only one I go to. The food is always good, the staff is great and it’s typically busy.

comments 3

Great staff and customer service. Tables are usually kept clean when I visit. And food is always fresh. Location is large, with lots of seatings, hence the 5 stars rating.

My only complaint (which is not relevant to the rating)- When I order food through Uber Eats, it is occasionally missing. Either food was mistakenly picked up by someone else or it’s stolen. Is there a better way to monitor who is actually picking up the food at this location? I prefer going up to the counter to provide my name everytime I have a pick up.

comments 4

Coming from nj this is honestly the best sandwich shop ive been to in a while. I highly recommend the avo turkey sandwich. All the ingredients are fresh and its doesnt break the bank. They also have salad options so the whole family can eat here. The original size is filling enough.For a sandwich and chips i spent $13.59. Big seating area to enjoy as well. Paid metered parking nearby

finally

I love their fireball sandwich (meatball plus chili off their underground menu). That and one if their always soft sugar cookies, is a perfect meal. The only downside is that it’s a but expensive (upwards of $10 just for the small version of the sandwich) so I can’t get it too often, but that just makes those rare times I do a special treat!